This Time It Is Different
For several years before the 2008
crisis, the Chief Economist of Morgan Stanley, Stephen Roach, was bearish about
the US economy and warned about excesses in the system. Then he changed his mind
and said things were fine. Unfortunately, that was just weeks before the crash.
And now Jeremy Grantham, the founder
of fund manager GMO, has thrown in the towel. Grantham called the 2000 and 2008
tops, and the 2009 bottom, but had been bearish on the stock market in recent
years. His poor fund performance as a result has caused investors to yank money
out of his fund, which has fallen from $ 124 billion under management in 2014
to about $ 80 billion now.
This is a real dilemma that fund
managers face. If a fund manager decides that markets are overvalued, becomes bearish and holds a large cash position or goes net short, his performance will
lag his peers, if the markets keep rising. Investors punish such funds managers
by withdrawing money from their funds. But if they stay invested regardless of how
concerned they are, then when there is a major crash, they cannot be held
responsible as all their peers will also have had major losses. This peer comparison
pressure creates substantial upward bias, and propels the bubble until it does
inevitably burst. The same logic applied in 2000 and 2008.
Apparently, the substantial loss of funds
under management due his bearish allocation has helped Grantham find religion. In
his Q1 2017 letter titled “This time seems very, very different” Grantham, an
avowed value investor, told the Financial Times that “I’ve dedicated my life to
financial bubbles, and I don’t think it is a bubble.”
He cites globalisation, increasingly
monopolistic US companies and super-low interest rates as having pushed
corporate profit margins well above their long-term average.
He presents the chart below as
evidence that the P/E ratio for US stocks since 1996 is now at a permanently
elevated level compared to earlier years, and so the current market P/E (Price/Earnings)
ratio of 26.1 (compared to the long term historical average of 17) is just
fine. Nothing to see here, folks.
Firstly, Mr. Grantham’s conversion
reminds me a lot of Mr. Roach’s change of mind at just the wrong time, and may
be a telling contrarian indicator that things may be about to go south in a
hurry.
Secondly, his argument sounds very
similar to Yale Economics Professor Irving Fischer’s in 1929 who, just days
before the Crash of 1929, expressed his expert opinion that stocks were not
overvalued: “Stock prices have reached a permanently high plateau.” As an
investor in the market, he eventually went bankrupt.
Thirdly, even if corporate profits
are at all-time highs, these elevated earnings are already included in the E
part of the P/E ratio. Investors are paying a lot more for the same dollar of
earnings.
Fourthly, earnings are subject to
accounting gimmicks. Let’s look at a more honest number, median price/revenues
for the S&P500. This ratio is now almost 2.5, the highest it has ever been.
At the peak of the 2008 bubble, the ratio was about 1.85.
So, if it is not record revenues that
are driving earnings and share prices, then what is?
As Credit Suisse analyst, Andrew
Graithwaite notes: “What this means is
that since the financial crisis, there has been only one buyer of stock:
the companies themselves, who have engaged in the greatest debt-funded buyback
spree in history.” Corporations have leveraged
themselves massively and corporate debt is at all-time levels, just to pay out
dividends and buy back their own shares.
The mirage of corporate profitability
has been driven by share buybacks, wage reduction, and productivity increases. There
is only so much you can cut costs before impairing the long term health of a
business.
And, finally, look at this chart. The
reason share prices are at record highs is the amount of easy money all around
the globe chasing financial assets and real estate.
It is basic economics that when demand
exceeds supply, prices will rise. So when there are trillions of dollars that
cannot find a decent yield in bonds, they will chase risk assets and bid up
prices. Rising prices do not necessarily indicate the health of an economy, nor fair value.
Unlike Mr. Grantham, I believe we are
in a massive bubble that is poised to burst. Rising interest rates and the
Federal Reserve’s stated intention to engage in Quantitative Tightening (QT)
later this year will pull liquidity out of the markets.
To truly understand how out of
balance things are, look at the chart below. Share prices have been boosted by
massive amounts of credit taken on by investors, particularly corporations.
Another less understood challenge is
how narrow the leadership in the US stock market has become. In 1996, there
were 7,300 publicly list companies in the US, today there are only less than 3,500
(excluding REITs, collective investment vehicles such as investment and mutual
funds, and over-the-counter listings), according to a 2015 report by the
National Bureau of Economic research. The number has shrunk due to mergers and acquisitions
and de-listings.
In 1975, the top 100 corporations
generated 48.5% of all corporate profits. In 2014,
that number was 84.2%! (Source:
Mark Hulbert, Marketwatch, June 12, 2017). Just 50 stocks account for about half
the capitalisation of the S&P 500.
So, when Grantham says “This is the
broadest market of all time… That is not the nature of a bubble” he doesn’t seem to understand how dangerously narrow the market
has actually become.
The VIX (which is a measure of greed
and fear in the markets) this month reached its third lowest level in history,
which means investors have no fear of the equity market falling. Investors are
ignoring any bad news they encounter: the collapse of the Trump legislative
agenda, North Korea’s nuclear saber rattling, the criminal investigation into election
collusion with the Russians, rising interest rates and QT, the first Moody's downgrade of China in 30 years, etc. None of it
matters, until it matters! This is now a confidence game and when confidence is
shattered, the rush to the exits will be dramatic.
Continue to accumulate REAL money, i.e., gold and silver, and be patient. "Be right and sit tight." -- Jesse Livermore
ReplyDelete